Dirt Pudding Cups

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

These dirt pudding cups, complete with gummy worms, are a perfect Halloween dessert that kids will love! Made with Oreos and a creamy peanut butter chocolate pudding, they take minutes to make and are perfect for spooky season!

Dirt pudding cups made with pudding and oreos

Ingredients & substitutions

Yogurt: Use a Greek yogurt to add a little extra protein to this dessert, and use a vanilla flavor for a little sweetness. You can also use plain yogurt,
Cream: Heavy cream helps to create a smooth pudding texture. Heavy cream works best as it helps to keep the pudding thick.
Honey: Used to naturally sweeten the pudding. Maple syrup can also be used.
Cocoa powder: Unsweetened coconut powder creates a rich chocolatey taste.
Peanut butter: This is optional, but peanut butter and chocolate is a favorite combination. Use smooth rather than crunchy for the best texture.
Vanilla extract and salt: To enhance the flavors of the pudding.
Sandwich cookies: Crushed Oreos make up the dirt layers, any hard chocolate cookies will work well.
Gummy worms: No chocolate dirt pudding is complete without some gummy worms! Other candy will work well, but worms are a must for us!

How to make dirt pudding cups

Add the ingredients for the chocolate pudding to a bowl.
Combine together in a stand blender or with a hand mixer til smooth.
Crush the Oreos into fine crumbs.
Layer cups with the two mixtures and top with gummy worms.

4 image collage to show how to make the pudding and then layer the cups

Tips for making the pudding

Freeze your Oreos before crushing them. Freeze them on a baking sheet for 30 minutes, then crush them with a food processor. You can also add them to a ziplock bag and crush them with a rolling pin.
Skip the peanut butter. We love to add peanut butter to the chocolate pudding, but you can skip it if you prefer plain chocolate. You could also use a fruit jam like raspberry or strawberry for a different flavor.
Don’t make them too far ahead of time. Although they will be save to eat, the biscuit crumbs will start to loose their crunch the longer the pudding sits.
Mix up your toppings. The gummy worms are so perfect for Halloween, but you can easily serve these up for other occasions. Add gummy hearts for Valentine’s or chocolate eggs for Easter!

Frequently asked questions

How far ahead of time can you make them?

We prefer to layer these dirt pudding cups just before serving so that the layers are more defined and the cookies don’t get soggy. You can make up the layers a day ahead of time and keep the covered and separate in the fridge til you are ready to serve.

How long do leftovers keep?

If you have leftover cups, cover them tightly and keep refrigerated. They will keep well for a couple of days.

Are they vegetarian?

The dirt pudding itself is vegetarian, but use gelatine free gummy worms to make them free from animal products.

Overhead shot of dirt pudding cups with gummy worms

These fun dirt pudding cups with gummy worms are the perfect Halloween treat that your kids will love! Simple and easy to make, they are a great option if you are hosting a party, or enjoy them for a fun evening in!

More halloween recipes:

If you try this healthy-ish feel good Dirt Pudding Cups recipe or any other recipe on Feel Good Foodie, then don’t forget to rate the recipe and leave a comment below! It helps others who are thinking of making the recipe. We would love to hear about your experience making it. And if you snapped some shots, share it on Instagram so we can repost on Stories!

Review